Culture

A Ludicrously Deep Dive Into the Birds of Spelling Bee, Wordle, Scrabble, and More

It’s only a game. It’s only a game.
Words by Jessica Leber
Deputy Editor, ԼƵ Magazine
Published May 02, 2022

When my alarm goes off each morning, I hit snooze, and I hit snooze again. Then I grab my phone and ease into the day with a game of Spelling Bee.

Spelling Bee is an addictiveword challenge game that becamepopular during the pandemic, only to be later eclipsed in fame by Wordle,anotherwordgame that recently took the internet by storm.Both are now run by the New York Times. In , a player uses seven letters to form as many as words as possible, aiming to achieve "genius" status.Each word must be at least four letters and contain that day'srequired letter.

There's one more catch: Not every possible word is accepted—and therefore, not every word is worthpoints. According to the puzzle’s : “Our word list does not include words that are offensive, obscure, hyphenated or proper nouns.”

For many game fans, the critical word is “obscure.” Jargon is a universal construct. Dive into any job or hobby or become familiar with any culture, or subculture, and you will inevitably develop a specialized lexicon that confuses outsiders. Foodies know a wider ranger ofdishes and ingredients than the average person on thestreet, for example, while gardeners know flowers and carpentersknow unusualtools.

Bird people also have their own unique dictionary—the most obviousentries being the names of birds themselves. Knowing about birds can confer an advantage at all kinds of word puzzles, whether in Spelling Bee or a classic game of Scrabble. But it also can be frustrating when a bird thatyou know isn’t valid.

Keep reading for a close look at some avian strategy for several popular word games. For puzzle fans who don’t know much about birds, you may gain an extra edge and hopefully a greater appreciation for the wide spectrum of avian diversity. And for bird fans who like puzzles, prepare to have opinions.

Spelling Bee

Since its digital debut in2018, Spelling Bee has published more than 1,400 daily puzzles.The unenviable task of arbitrating which words are and aren’t obscure is led byNew York Times digital puzzles editor , who through a spokesperson declinedwhat (I thought) was an irresistible opportunity to be interviewed about avian curation strategy.

Without his input, I turned to surveying colleagues and Twitter. I alsorelied heavilyon the excellent , a site with daily puzzle hints and created by puzzle aficionado William Shunn; all statistics below come from my searches ofhis site.(Note: Playing Spelling Beebeyond the early levels requires a New York Times Games subscription, though you can also findsimilar free- and ad-supported versions of this game. Those puzzles, however, may use differentword lists).

Accepted Birds So Far, By Number of Puzzle Appearances*

  • >50 appearances: Dodo (73), Nene (71); Loon (70);Coot (57)
  • 20-50: Pipit (34); Tomtit (27); Booby (25); Gull (23); Myna (21)
  • 10-20: Eagle (12); Lark (12); Cockatoo (11)
  • 6-10: Peahen, Raptor(8); Parrot (8); Mallard (7); Mynah (6)
  • 2-5: Cuckoo, Pewee (5); Crow, Titmice, Condor, Martin (4); Whippoorwill, Bobolink, Towhee (3); Finch, Robin, Toucan, Chicken, Dove (2)
  • 1: Peafowl; Hawk; Wigeon; Duck; Junco; Puffin; Bunting; Hawk; Owlet; Penguin

*This is a relatively comprehensive list butprobably nota complete one.

According to Spelling Bee Solver, Dodoand Nene are among the appearing words in all of the game, closely followed by Loons. It's a littlesad that of the three, Dodos are extinct, and ŧŧwere with only 30 birds left in the wild. (Today their populations and are viewed as an inspiring example of successful intervention to save a species).

That ŧŧare accepted at all issurprising. Evolved from Canada Geese and native only to the Hawaiian islands, they should be obscure birds to most people who don’t live or visit there. WilliamShunn theorizes, however, that these birds may be especially familiar to word puzzle fans. Well before Spelling Bee ever existed, ŧŧshave been popular inclusions in crossword puzzles (more on the reasons for that below). It is also worth noting thatSpelling Bee’s “Nene” may be considered misspelled by some. As aNative Hawaiian word, it should be , with the to lengthen and add stress to the “e” pronunciation.

Each Spelling Bee puzzle contains at least one pangram—a word that contains all seven letters and is worth extra points. While writing this article, I learned that I completely missed the March 2022 pangram “whippoorwill”—the only bird pangram to appear so far in the game. I felt aghast at my oversight. Andyet, its inclusion three times in the puzzle has turned out among those keeping score. According to the dictionary, as well as ԼƵ’s Field Guide, “whip-poor-will” should contain hyphens, which would really exclude it from the game.

In the end, I’m glad when more birds are accepted rather than fewer, such as Tomtits (adorably birds in New Zealand), wigeons (a group of dabbling ducks with an alternate spelling of "widgeons"), pewees (a group of flycatchers) and two spellings of Myna/Mynah. They are great birds. But before I began learning a lot about birds a few years ago, I would not have known some of these. I can certainly understand why relatively specialized birds frustrate some players.

Two Controversial Birds That Have Flipped

  • Nuthatch: Disallowed once in August 2018; allowed twice in 2020 and 2021.
  • Linnet: Disallowed five times from 2019-2020; allowed five times in 2021.

I have a theory that Sam Ezersky has been learning a lot of new birds as he has worked on the Spelling Bee puzzle. Feeling like a criminal profiler, I unearth a circumstantial clue: In 2018, just before Spelling Bee launched, he used the term “sea gull” in he wrote. While I am the last person who would ever correct someone who says “sea gull”—it’s quite unwelcoming to birdsplain such inconsequential distinctions to beginners—it is true that most birders would have simply gone with the word “gull” instead.

This flimsy piece of evidence may help explain why “nuthatch” was at first disallowed in 2018, shortly after the puzzle launched online. Perhaps Ezersky didn’t know a lot about birds back then and therefore didn'trealize how many people would be fans of thesecommon, charismatic feeder visitors and year-round residents. By 2020, he had changed his tune.

Some Banned Birds, By Number of Times Disallowed

  • >50: Motmot (53); Caracara (52)
  • 20-50: Potoo (39); Aracari (31); Bulbul (21)
  • 10-20: Pitta, Chachalaca (19); Graylag (10)
  • 5-10: Galah (9); Drongo (6); Willet, Trogon (5)
  • 2-5: Noddy, Dunlin, Hoopoe (4); Poorwill, Brant, Turaco (3); Anhinga, Woodlark, Munia (2)
  • 1: Parula;Gannet
  • Bonus Bird Slang Exclusions: floof (30); birb (19)

If we’re trying to avoid birds that a general audience wouldn’t know, I agree with most of these decisions (though I cannot abide the shunning of "floof"). The indie rock musician who just wrote an entire book about caracaras—among the most intelligent of all birds of prey—certainly , however. And I am initially surprised that Brant(a winter bird that can be seen in New York City, where I live) isn’t allowed, until I look up the bird’s geographic range and remember not everyone lives on the East or West coastline.

Other bird exclusions may reveal an East coast geographic bias on the part of the puzzle creators at the New York Times. Some playershave wondered why “whippoorwill”—a bird of the Eastern United States—counts, whereas “poorwill,” a common bird of the Western United States, is a no-go.

Reading the tea leaves is tough, even for experts. “It's difficult to figure out why some birds make the cut but others don't,” Shunn, of Spelling Bee Solver, writes me in an email. “Sometimes I think it might have to do with geography, since New York has the "towhee" (accepted twice) but not the "anhinga" (rejected twice). But then why does 'nene'make the cut 69 times and counting, while it takes an outcry from bird-lovers to get 'linnet'moved from the endangered column to protected status? All I can conclude is that it comes down to one individual's judgment on whether or not a bird is sufficiently well-known to make the cut.”

Even when high on my own morsel of power as an editor for ԼƵ.org, my word choices aren’t nearly as scrutinized as Ezersky’s. I can imagine it’s a lot of pressure. Shunn agrees: “Every day on Twitter I see people criticizing Sam—some in a light-hearted way, but others in a less kind tone—for his supposed prejudices, blindspots, and ignorance.” Perhaps that's why the New York Times declined my interview request: Spelling Bee is too hot of a topic.

So I will end this section with an important reminder: It’s just a game. Maybe we can all remember that and chill out a little when ourword isn't accepted.

Side Note: Birds That Have Not Yet—and May Never—Appear in Spelling Bee

Interestingly, there’s a far longer list of birds that could, in theory, be included within Spelling Bee solutions but have not yet appeared as possibilities in any published puzzle. As a result, they have yet to be ruled upon by the powers that be. According to Spelling Bee Solver’s search tool, this includes birds such as: Goose; Grebe; Sparrow; Pigeon; Crane; Warbler; Catbird; Grouse; Vireo; Wren; Oriole; Heron; Killdeer; Siskin; Plover; Ibis; Spoonbill; Falcon; Raven; Avocet; Thrush; Pelican; Cardinal; Godwit; Phoebe; Magpie, Chickadee; Turkey; and Quail.

I’m definitely surprised that birds like grebe and goose and ibis have not yet appeared, given that they only comprise a few common letters. But Shunn tells me that the puzzle usually avoids the letter “s,” as well as the combination of “e” and “r” together, because of the very long word list including these letters would create. That does help explain the omission of many (but not all) birds above. I do hope one day we see cardinalas a pangram.

Wordle

Brooklyn-based software developer Josh Wardle launched Wordle to the public in October 2021 and it soon wentviral, later to be acquired by the New York Times (it remains free). The game launched with a predefined list of about 2,500 commonly known five-letter words that could solve the puzzle, selected . Each word would eventually appear as the solution to a daily puzzle, unraveling over the course of a few years.

Warning: Below are spoilers for Wordle games that have already appeared, so please keep scrolling if you will be upset by this.The dates andnumbers of the puzzles are not included.

So far, three birds have appeared as answers to Wordle’s daily puzzles, according to several unofficial lists I unearthedonline. The first, booby, has , so I’m not going to overanalyze that one. The other two—heron and robin —are unsurprisingly very common kinds of birds. A fourth bird-related term, "moult,” reveals creator Wardle’s British-born roots and appeared as an answer in the weeks before the game was widely released to the public. In the United States, we would spell this as “molt.”

Now that the New York Times owns the game, it'sunlikely we would see solutions that use British spellings. I suspect there will be additional common birds that we see as future Wordle answers, such as goose,geese, and eagle.But I think we are evenless likely to see more obscure birds here thanin Spelling Bee. It would ruin too many streaks.

Luckily, for bird enthusiasts, there is a much larger aviary acceptable as guesses into each Wordle puzzle. In fact, drawing from , I could not find a single bird that was rejected as a guess (and birds like Galahand Serin,being not of this hemisphere, were completely unfamiliar to me).

If you are inclined to start your Wordle with a strategic bird word—i.e. one that contains many common letters—some good bets might be: Robin; Snipe; Brant; and Serin. Each of these words contains four out of the nine most commonly used letters in the English language. And for an even tougher avian challenge, try an alternative version of the game: BRDL, by ԼƵ graphic designer Alex Tomlinson.

Crosswords

Great crossword players thrive on obscure trivia and clever word play. People who design crossword puzzles, however, tend to have a few go-towords that are especially useful for fitting the puzzle together. That leads to a term called “crosswordese,” which refers to words that are found far more frequently in U.S. crosswords than in regular conversation. These tend to be short words that fit into particular constraints; many will start or end in vowels or contain frequently used letters.

So which birds are crosswordese? The New York Times’s very own Sam Ezersky answered that question for us in article explaining 12 popular crossword birds. Nene is among them, which certainly accounts for theSpelling Bee bias.

Another top pick is the Emu, a flightless, fast Australian bird that appears so frequently that Ezersky suggests going deep on trivia beyond those obvious facts (for example, emus have large green eggs and are hunted by dingos). Ernes or Erns—an alternative names forsea-eagles—were news to me. Eiders are among my favorite birds, and they apparently appear a lot because of their unusual vowel pattern. Other favorites: Auks, Smews, and Terns. You can study the Times piece for more detail. For whatever reason, the list seems to be mostly ducks, seabirds, and flightless birds.

Scrabble

Excellent Scrabble players are next level, and I am not one of them. To get good, it pays to know as many unique words and terms as you can. Based on a spot check of the official , it’s clear that pretty much any kind of bird will be good here—but watch for hyphens. While “whippoorwill” will win you high points in Spelling Bee, but if you try that in Scrabble and are challenged, the dictionary’s “whip-poor-will” will rule you out.

Perhaps the of all are quetzals,which are truly stunning birds in the trogon family that are native to forests in Central America and Mexico (they are Guatemala’s national bird and also the name for its currency). One bird, the Eared Quetzal, surprisedbirders by expanding its range as far as Arizona in the 1970s.

The two letters “Q” and “Z” are worth 10 points each—the highest values in the game—and they are arranged in such a way that, in theory, it’s to land on a double letter score and two triple word scores using the plural version.

A “jay” is also a perfect short bird word to have in your back pocket, as the letter “J” can both offer high points and be a challenging letter to use (there is only one in the game). Birds with lots of vowels in them—such as hoopoe and oriole—are also great to keep in mind for moments when you have too many in your hand and need to dump some. As any Scrabble player knows, having too many vowels can make for a frustrating game.

When you're done, whether you need to shake off a loss or celebrate a win, I have the perfect activity: Get outsideand see somebirds.