Learn to Tell a Northern Shrike From a Loggerhead Shrike
These are the best clues to help you know which ‘butcherbird’ is which.
When it comes to songbirds, shrikes are a bloodthirsty bunch. They’ve earned the name “butcher birds” for the way they impale their prey on thorns or barbed wire. Preferring to hunt in open areas, they'll perch on the very top branches of trees or on powerlines to watch for prey. Their targets can include anything from cardinals and lizards to grasshoppers and mice.
Here in North America we have exactly two species of butcherbirds: the medium-sized Northern Shrike (also know as the Great Grey Shrike) and the somewhat smaller Loggerhead Shrike. If you live in the northern United States, you can see the Loggerhead Shrike in summer and the Northern Shrike in winter (they breed up in the taiga and tundra). In the extreme southern states, you only get the Loggerhead year round. But what do you do in the middle of the country where their winter ranges overlap? The secret to identifying adult shrikes is all in the face. Hover over the points on the photos below to reveal some of the key differences.
Loggerhead Shrike
- Beak- Smaller and usually all black
- Mask- Thick and bold, starting at the base of the beak and spreading well past the eye
- Chest- Clean, no barring in spring
- Size- Can be up to an inch smaller than the Northern Shrike
Other notes: The immature version of this bird is much grayer, and has dark barring across its chest. In flight, the white "hankerchief" on the wing is more prominent than on the juvenile Northern.
Northern Shrike
- Beak- Thicker with obvious pale base in fall and early winter
- Eye- Thin white stripe bordering top of mask
- Mask- Slimmer, only starts at juncture of eye and beak
- Plumage- Frostier with more white mixed in with gray
Other notes: In immature Northern Shrikes, the mask is practically a smudge and barely visible. The young birds are also more brown than gray.
Species that shrikes might be confused with include Northern Mockingbirds, Clark’s Nutcrackers, and Townsend’s Solitaires. Yet their hooked beaks, beefy heads, and distinct behavior set them apart from other birds. (Any blood is also a good clue.) If you see a passerine hovering and hunting in a clearing, there’s no doubt: You’re about to see a butcherbird get down to business.
For more diagrams and side-by-side comparisons of the two species, check out by Canadian ornithologist Ron Pittaway.